I sent this note to my New York elected officials. I would ask that you do the same regarding Guidance on Private Transfer Fee Covenants,(No. 2010-N-11): 415 E 85 Exterior Cherry Blossom for web

The proposed Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA) guidance that would prohibit Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac from buying mortgages on property that have a private transfer tax fee agreement, or a “Flip Tax” as it is known in New York, would seriously disrupt the stability and efficiency of the city’s housing market.

The New York City condo and co-op housing market has operated with a flip tax for some time.  In one study, it was reported that more than 50 percent of the co-ops in New York City have a flip tax. In many cases, the flip tax is paid by the seller and is a percentage of the seller’s profit.

This tax has bolstered the capital reserve fund of numerous buildings thereby funding critical and necessary capital improvements, including facade work which ensures public safety. These improvements have benefited the residents of these buildings and the surrounding neighborhood.

In New York these fees are going back to the property for the benefit of the building and its occupants, not to the building developer.  These fees typically fund building maintenance, the repair and replacement of building systems, and additional building wide improvements that benefit the residents. FHFA is principally concerned with the private transfer fee covenant when the project developer, or their designated third-party receives the proceeds, not when the fee goes to improve the operation of the building.

We urge you to drop this current proposal which would harm New York City’s housing market. In my opinion, condos and co-ops in New York City are sounder investments for Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac as a result of a building’s healthy reserve fund which in most cases has been funded through flip and transfer taxes.

Lee can be reached at (347)829-9996.
Apartments in Manhattan

Advertisements